Islamabad, November 18,2026: The International Commission of Jurists (ICJ) has said that Pakistan’s 26th and 27th Constitutional Amendments have resulted in “systemic judicial capture”, undermining the independence of the judiciary and weakening the rule of law.
In a report released on Wednesday titled Judicial Capture: Independence of the Judiciary in Pakistan after the 26th and 27th Constitutional Amendments, the ICJ said its analysis of the institutional framework governing the higher judiciary showed that Pakistan’s courts no longer enjoyed the institutional guarantees of independence required under international law and standards.
The 26th Amendment, passed in October 2024, introduced constitutional benches in the Supreme Court, with their members selected by a reconstituted Judicial Commission of Pakistan (JCP), in which judges no longer held a majority.
The 27th Amendment, passed a year later, transformed the constitutional benches into a separate Federal Constitutional Court (FCC). It also introduced significant changes to the judicial system and the military’s chain of command while granting immunities to certain government officials. Two of the Supreme Court’s senior-most judges resigned in protest on the day the amendment became law.
The ICJ described the two amendments as a decisive departure from the model of judicial independence developed after the restoration of the judiciary in 2009.
The report observed that the erosion of judicial independence had been carried out through constitutional amendments rather than the direct removal of judges.
It acknowledged the government’s arguments that the amendments were intended to check judicial overreach, reduce case backlogs, address perceived politicisation of the Supreme Court’s original jurisdiction and give Parliament a role in judicial appointments comparable to that of legislatures in other democracies.
However, the commission said these objectives did not justify restructuring the judiciary in a manner that was inconsistent with Pakistan’s obligations under international law.
While acknowledging that the Supreme Court had at times encroached upon the roles of Parliament and other institutions, the report said Parliament had failed to address these shortcomings while preserving judicial independence.
Instead, it said, the amendments had enabled other branches of the state to exercise systemic control over the judiciary, weakening the rule of law.
The ICJ further alleged that the ruling coalition had exploited public grievances over the functioning of the courts in a self-serving manner to gain control over the judiciary.
As a result, it said, even the country’s highest courts could no longer effectively serve as a check on the executive or Parliament, while their ability to provide remedies to victims of human rights violations had been seriously impaired.
In its recommendations, the ICJ urged the government to initiate a comprehensive review of the two amendments and their implementation in light of international law and standards, particularly Pakistan’s obligations under the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR).
It also called for transparent and broad-based public consultations as part of the review process.
The commission recommended international cooperation, including seeking technical assistance from the UN Special Rapporteur on the independence of judges and lawyers and inviting the mandate holder to undertake a country visit.
Addressing the Judicial Commission of Pakistan, the report called for revising the criteria for judicial appointments in line with international law, established standards and best practices.
It recommended that published criteria serve as the sole basis for nominating judges to the Federal Constitutional Court, Supreme Court, high courts and constitutional benches of the high courts.
The ICJ also urged the JCP to establish transparent appointment procedures and publish reasons for each appointment, demonstrating how the prescribed criteria had been applied. It further called on the commission to refrain from transferring high court judges without their consent.
For the Supreme Judicial Council, the report recommended defining “inefficiency” in accordance with international standards, limiting it to serious incompetence that renders a judge unfit to perform judicial duties.
The commission also urged the Special Parliamentary Committee, which has the authority to nominate the Chief Justice of Pakistan, to adopt clear and transparent criteria and procedures for selecting the heads of the Supreme Court and Federal Constitutional Court and publicly disclose the reasons behind each selection.
Finally, the ICJ called on the Federal Constitutional Court, Supreme Court and high courts to interpret and apply the provisions of the 26th and 27th Amendments, to the greatest extent possible, in a manner consistent with judicial independence guaranteed under Article 14 of the ICCPR.





